The answer is, it depends on the intended application.
When it comes to price, raw aluminum is usually more affordable than aluminum alloy, stainless steel, and other common alloys. (Although it’s more expensive than carbon steels.) This is because raw aluminum has a simpler composition, with fewer extra components, so it’s easier and more cost-effective to produce.
Raw aluminum usually has a low melting point, which makes it malleable. But its softness is also one reason why it’s not durable and strong enough for most industrial applications.
An aluminum alloy is thirty times stronger than aluminum and even beats steel in terms of strength-to-weight ratios. But in general, carbon steel (which predominantly consists of pure iron atoms) is still stronger than aluminum alloys when it comes to hardness and tensile strength.
Raw aluminum is more corrosion-resistant than these alloys because it creates an oxide layer that stops further corrosion or oxidation. On the other hand, the additional elements in an aluminum alloy could change the properties of base metal on its surface, preventing it from forming a protective oxide layer.
Overall, raw aluminum is valued for being corrosion-resistant and lightweight. Due to its alloying elements, an aluminum alloy tends to be stronger, more durable, and more versatile. Manufacturers can also customize the composition of aluminum and steel alloys to meet the specific performance requirements of different industries.